Skip to content

Brazilian health law · health plans and the SUS

Insulin pump refused? Understand the legal criteria before taking action

STJ Theme 1.316 established parameters for claims against health plans. Coverage is not automatic: clinical documentation, the prior request and the requirements of the case must be checked.

Informational legal content. It does not replace medical assessment or promise coverage or a court decision.

Health professional and adult patient discussing treatment follow-up

Medical indication and legal evidence go together

A prescription is necessary, but assessment requires other evidence.

Theme 1.316

Criteria established by the STJ in March 2026

Individual evidence

Prescription, alternative in the Rol and regulatory registration

Sensitive data

Initial contact does not request tests or medical files

Repetitive appeal ruling

What the STJ decided about health plans

Theme 1.316 standardised interpretation concerning continuous insulin infusion systems while retaining technical assessment for each patient.

The STJ recognised the immediate application of Law No 14.454/2022 to health plan contracts and rejected automatic classification of pumps within the statutory exclusions examined. Contract terms excluding the system on that basis are invalid.

As the technology is not in the ANS Rol, the ruling requires compliance with the parameters established by the STF and distinguishes common points already recognised by the court from matters requiring individual proof.

Please note: there is no automatic authorisation. The court requires a prior request, individual evidence and technical assessment; insufficient documentation may lead to refusal.

When to assess the case

Situations that may call for legal advice

The reason for refusal, where the request was made and the available documentation affect the strategy.

  • The health plan refused the pump because it is absent from the ANS List of Health Procedures and Events (Rol).
  • The operator has not answered the request or has exceeded a reasonable time without offering a solution.
  • Authorisation was partial and excluded the equipment or a supply item expressly requested.
  • There is a medical prescription, but the plan proposes an alternative treatment which the doctor considers unsuitable for the case.
  • The person has already bought the equipment or supplies following a refusal and wants to assess possible reimbursement.
  • An administrative request to the SUS has not resulted in provision, and the appropriate route and public authority need to be identified.
  • A court has already issued a decision, but provision or continuity of treatment is not being complied with.
  • Treatment has changed, requiring a new prescription, a different equipment model or a review of the supplies requested.

Understanding the ruling correctly

What has already been recognised and what still needs proof

Theme 1.316 did not create a single list of six patient documents. It distinguished common criteria, individual requirements and the court's verification duties.

Common points recognised by the STJ

Regulatory position at the ANS

In the repetitive appeal ruling, the STJ treated as satisfied the criterion concerning the absence of an express refusal or pending proposal to update the ANS Rol for the technology.

Evidence of effectiveness and safety

The decision recognised, as a point common to these cases, high-level scientific evidence of the effectiveness and safety of continuous insulin infusion systems.

Decision not to incorporate the technology

The STJ also examined the administrative decision not to incorporate the technology. These common points do not remove the need for individual patient evidence.

Individual evidence and judicial checks

Prescription by the treating doctor

A qualified professional must prescribe the requested treatment, identifying it and ensuring consistency with the documented clinical condition.

No suitable alternative in the Rol

It must be shown that the options in the ANS Rol do not include a suitable therapeutic substitute for the particular condition.

Valid Anvisa registration

The equipment requested must have valid regulatory registration. Its model, manufacturer and registration status must be checked.

Prior request to the operator

Judicial assessment must check for a prior request and refusal, unreasonable delay or failure to respond. Keep reference numbers and the written response.

Technical support for the court

The STJ required prior consultation with NatJus or experts, where available. A prescription is necessary, but must not be the decision's only technical basis.

Two different routes

Health plans and the SUS are not governed by the same ruling

The legal grounds and responsible authority depend on where the request is made.

Private health plan

STJ Theme 1.316

Assessment covers the contract, request to the operator, refusal or delay, ANS Rol, prescription, suitable therapeutic alternative, Anvisa registration and judicial technical support.

Sistema Único de Saúde (SUS)

Its own administrative and judicial route

The pump remains unincorporated into the SUS under the official recommendation consulted. The administrative request, evidence, jurisdiction, responsible authority and applicable health litigation standards require specific assessment.

A ruling concerning private plans does not automatically produce the same result in a claim against public authorities.

Documents

What generally needs to be organised

This list is a guide. The firm does not produce medical reports or interfere with treatment choices.

The clinical report must be prepared independently by the responsible health professional. The lawyer's role is to check whether the facts and documents meet the applicable criteria.

  • An up-to-date prescription, medical report and history of treatments already used.
  • Tests and clinical records which the doctor considers relevant to justify the prescription.
  • The request made to the plan, reference numbers, written response, emails and contact records.
  • Membership card, contract or plan identification and evidence of compliance, where relevant.
  • Pump name and model, manufacturer and Anvisa registration check.
  • An itemised list of supplies requested, quantities and replacement frequency.
  • Invoices and proof of payment, if items were purchased following the refusal.
  • For the SUS, the administrative request, response received and documents identifying the unit responsible for follow-up.

Before filing

Points that may weaken or prevent a claim

Identifying a gap before administrative or judicial action allows it to be addressed where possible.

  • Not having made an administrative request or being unable to prove refusal, failure to respond or significant delay.
  • Submitting a generic report without explaining why the available alternatives are unsuitable for the case.
  • Requesting a model without valid regulatory registration or sufficient identification for checking.
  • Confusing the ruling on private health plans with the SUS route, which has different legal grounds and jurisdictional rules.
  • Requesting equipment and supplies generically without specifying the prescribed items.
  • Sending tests, diagnoses, ICD codes or other health data through an open form before an appropriate channel has been agreed.

Legal advice

How assessment may be structured

The process preserves the purpose of initial contact and separates screening from analysis of medical documents.

  1. 01

    Initial screening without sensitive documents

    The first contact collects only basic details and a summary of the refusal, delay or failure to respond.

  2. 02

    Assessment of the applicable route

    We check whether the case involves a private plan, the SUS, reimbursement or enforcement of an existing decision.

  3. 03

    Document checks

    The prescription, report, treatment history, reference number, refusal and regulatory registration are examined together.

  4. 04

    Choosing the action to take

    Depending on the case, this may involve supplementing the request, a regulatory complaint, out-of-court action or court proceedings.

  5. 05

    Ongoing assistance

    Deadlines, responses, any technical support and compliance with measures are followed up without any promise of an outcome.

Alex Rodrigues Alves, the Brazilian lawyer responsible for assistance

Who advises you

Alex Rodrigues Alves

Lawyer with multidisciplinary education and postgraduate qualifications in Brazilian public law and constitutional law, fields relevant to assessing state duties, fundamental rights, contracts and consumer relations in health disputes.

  • Postgraduate qualification in Brazilian public law
  • Postgraduate qualification in Brazilian constitutional law
  • Education in Law, Accounting and Economics
  • Practice in Brazilian consumer law

These qualifications are not presented as medical or health law specialisations.

View education and professional registrations →

Frequently asked questions

Questions about insulin pumps

The answers provide general parameters and do not replace individual clinical or legal assessment.

Must a health plan provide an insulin pump?

The STJ established criteria for assessing coverage. The ruling prevents automatic exclusion of the system under the statutory provisions examined, but each case must still show a prescription, no suitable alternative in the Rol, valid Anvisa registration and a prior request with refusal, unreasonable delay or failure to respond.

Does Theme 1.316 automatically guarantee a pump for every patient?

No. The ruling standardised legal criteria but does not replace individual evidence. The court must examine the case and seek technical support where available.

Is a medical prescription alone sufficient?

Not necessarily. It is essential, but the STJ directed that a decision must not rely solely on the treating doctor's prescription or report and provided for consultation with NatJus or experts where available.

Must I ask the plan before going to court?

Theme 1.316 requires a check for a prior request and refusal, unreasonable delay or failure to respond. It is therefore important to register the request and keep all reference numbers.

Must the refusal be provided in writing?

A clear, traceable response helps explain the reason and prove what happened. Ask for a formal response and keep reference numbers, messages and documents received.

Can I complain to the ANS?

After contacting the operator and keeping the reference number, the beneficiary can complain to the ANS through its Preliminary Mediation Notification (Notificação de Intermediação Preliminar). Its usefulness depends on the urgency and circumstances.

Are pump supplies also included in the request?

Equipment and supplies must be identified in the prescription and administrative request. Coverage of each item must be assessed according to its purpose, registration, contract and case documents; general coverage of any material should not be presumed.

Can the plan propose another treatment?

Whether there is a suitable therapeutic alternative in the Rol is central. If the treating doctor considers the alternative unsuitable, the report must explain the technical reasons, which will still be assessed in the proceedings.

Can an urgent decision be requested?

Urgent measures may be considered where evidence shows a likelihood of entitlement and risk of harm. Whether and when relief is granted depends on the evidence and the court's decision.

Can someone who has already paid for a pump seek reimbursement?

Reimbursement may be argued in some situations, but depends on the contract, refusal, urgency, proof of payment and applicable case law. It is not automatic.

Does the SUS provide insulin pumps?

Continuous insulin infusion technology remains unincorporated into the SUS under the official recommendation consulted. This does not make court action automatic: the administrative request, evidence, jurisdiction, responsible authority and standards for health litigation must be assessed individually.

Does Theme 1.316 apply to the SUS?

Theme 1.316 was decided in a dispute concerning health plan operators. Claims against public authorities follow a different legal framework and require their own assessment.

Does this page replace a medical consultation?

No. The firm does not prescribe treatments, change medical care or prepare clinical reports. Treatment decisions must be made with qualified health professionals.

Can I send test results through the form?

Do not send tests, diagnoses, ICD codes, prescriptions or medical files through this initial form. Health data is sensitive; if the assessment proceeds, the firm will identify an appropriate channel for the documents needed.

Can services be provided online?

Yes. The firm offers online appointments throughout Brazil and in-person appointments in Ceilândia Sul, Brasília/DF, depending on availability and the nature of the matter.

WhatsApp messages can be received in different languages. Telephone calls are available in Portuguese, English and Spanish.

Initial contact

Provide only a summary of the refusal

Give your contact details, city, plan or authority involved and briefly state whether there was refusal, delay or failure to respond.

Protection of health data

Do not include diagnoses, ICD codes, test results or clinical details, or send prescriptions or medical files at this initial contact. Health data is sensitive; if assessment proceeds, the firm will identify an appropriate channel.

This form prepares a message in your browser. Avoid health information, information about children and details of legal proceedings. See the Privacy Policy.

WhatsApp