Skip to content

Brazilian health law · Brazilian consumer law

Health plan refused? Learn what to check first

Surgery, medication, therapy, hospital admission or other care may be refused for different reasons. The reference number, formal refusal, medical indication and position under the ANS Rol guide the next step.

Informational content, with no promise of reversal, compensation, timeframe or court decision.

Client and professional examining a written health plan response

The operator's response must be understandable

The reference number, reason and legal basis help guide assessment.

ADI 7.265

Current criteria for treatment outside the Rol

RN 623/2024

Reference number, traceability and detailed refusal

Online advice

Legal assessment for different Brazilian states

Start here

Four steps after receiving a refusal

These steps help preserve important information without replacing medical advice or requiring immediate engagement of the firm.

  1. 01

    Keep the reference number and refusal

    The operator must provide a reference number at the start of contact. If authorisation is refused, it must formally explain the reason in plain language, identifying the contractual or legal basis used.

  2. 02

    Talk to the treating doctor

    The prescription and report must explain the proposed treatment, the history and, where relevant, why the alternatives offered are unsuitable.

  3. 03

    Do not stop treatment on your own

    Clinical decisions belong to the patient and health professionals. In urgent or emergency situations, seek medical assistance immediately.

  4. 04

    Consider a complaint to the ANS

    After contact with the operator, the NIP can mediate the complaint. Whether it is appropriate to wait for this stage depends on urgency and the individual case.

If there is immediate risk

Seek medical care or emergency services. Legal assessment can proceed alongside this but must not delay necessary clinical assistance.

Treatment outside the Rol

The STF established five cumulative criteria

In ADI 7.265, decided in September 2025, the STF retained the ANS Rol as a reference and defined exceptional circumstances for coverage.

01

Clinical prescription

Treatment must be prescribed by a duly qualified treating doctor or dentist.

02

Position at the ANS

There must be no express refusal by the ANS or pending assessment of a proposal to update the Rol for the treatment.

03

No suitable alternative

It must be shown that no suitable therapeutic alternative for the particular condition is already included in the ANS Rol.

04

Proven effectiveness and safety

The prescribed treatment must have scientific evidence of effectiveness and safety under evidence-based medicine.

05

Regulatory registration

The medicine, product or device must have valid Anvisa registration.

When a procedure is already in the Rol, the dispute may concern a usage guideline, contract, waiting period, network, material or another specific rule. Inclusion in the Rol does not remove the need for document assessment.

Judicial oversight

The prescription is not the only evidence

Alongside the five criteria, the STF defined steps courts must observe when assessing treatment outside the Rol.

  • Check for a prior request to the operator and refusal, unreasonable delay or failure to respond.
  • Assess the administrative decision not to incorporate the treatment into the Rol in the circumstances, without replacing the ANS's technical judgement.
  • Consult NatJus or available experts beforehand, without deciding solely on the prescription or report submitted by the party.
  • If treatment is granted, notify the ANS so it can consider possible inclusion in the Rol.

Types of refusal

Common refusals, different grounds

This page provides general guidance. Each category requires checks on specific rules and case documents.

Surgery or procedure

Refusal due to a waiting period, contractual coverage, usage guideline, technique employed or disagreement about materials.

Medication

Assessment varies with Anvisa registration, route of administration, home use, purpose and inclusion in the Rol.

Treatment outside the Rol

Requires the cumulative criteria established by the STF in ADI 7.265 and individual evidence.

Insulin pump and supplies

Subject to specific criteria established by the STJ in Theme 1.316.

See specific guidance →

Therapies and multidisciplinary care

Refused or limited sessions require checks on the diagnosis, proposed method and current ANS rules.

Home care

Hospital-level care at home may be covered when replacing hospital admission, subject to indication, agreement and the other requirements of the case.

Orthoses, prostheses and materials

It must be checked whether the material is linked to a covered procedure, its purpose, registration and any statutory exclusion.

Hospital admission

Refusal, interruption or time limits must be examined against medical indication, the contract and STJ Súmula 302.

Urgent care, emergencies and waiting periods

Medical classification, the contractual period and the rules of Law No 9.656/1998 must be examined together.

Pre-existing illness or injury

The health declaration, any prior examination, temporary partial coverage and allegations of bad faith are central points.

Out-of-network care

Network availability, prior contact and the options offered affect possible payment or reimbursement.

Cancellation during treatment

Whether the plan is individual, family or group-based, and the reason for termination, change the applicable rules.

Have you received detailed reasons for refusal?

The operator's response and medical report are central to assessment.

Contact the firm

Possible routes

The appropriate action depends on urgency and evidence

Routes may complement each other. Not every case needs to start with court proceedings.

Operator and ombudsman

RN 623/2024 provides for traceability, a clear response and possible reassessment of healthcare requests. Supplementing documents may resolve the disagreement.

Complaint to the ANS

The NIP is free. The operator has five working days to answer healthcare complaints and ten working days for other complaints.

Procon or negotiation

May help with contractual issues, reimbursement and information failures where there is no clinical risk requiring an immediate response.

Court action

May be considered when administrative action does not resolve the issue or urgency and evidence justify judicial measures.

Current STJ position

Non-material damage does not follow automatically from refusal

In Repetitive Appeal Theme 1.365, decided in March 2026, the STJ held that an improper refusal of coverage alone does not give rise to presumed non-material damage. Other factors and effects sufficient to go beyond ordinary upset or inconvenience must be demonstrated.

There is no compensation tariff or predictable amount; assessment depends on the actual effects of the conduct.

Documents

What generally supports assessment

Medical documents must be produced by the responsible professionals with clinical independence.

Reference number and detailed refusal

Letter, app, email or other record with the date, reason and stated contractual or legal basis.

Prescription and medical report

These must identify the treatment and give clinical reasons, without the lawyer interfering with the health professional's independence.

Treatment history

Tests, reports and records of treatments used, according to clinical relevance.

Contract and membership card

These help identify plan type, coverage segment, term, network, geographical scope and waiting-period rules.

Proof of payment

May be relevant to contractual compliance and any discussion about cancellation.

Reassessment request or NIP

Reference numbers and administrative responses show the steps already taken and the operator's arguments.

Invoices and receipts

If treatment was paid for privately, documents help examine possible reimbursement, which is not automatic.

Regulatory registration and evidence

For requests outside the Rol, Anvisa registration and relevant scientific evidence must be checked.

Transparency

Points that may weaken or prevent a claim

Prior assessment also identifies risks and avoids expectations inconsistent with the documentation.

  • A request without a reference number, formal refusal or evidence of significant delay.
  • A generic report that does not individualise the indication or explain why available alternatives are unsuitable.
  • Treatment outside the Rol lacking any of the cumulative criteria established in ADI 7.265.
  • A product without valid Anvisa registration or a home-use medicine falling within a statutory exclusion.
  • No contractual coverage compatible with the segment purchased, subject to statutory rules.
  • Non-payment, cancellation or pre-existing illness considered without examining plan type and contractual history.
  • Expecting compensation merely because of the refusal, without evidence of effects beyond ordinary upset.
  • Sending tests, ICD codes or other health data through an open form before an appropriate channel is agreed.

Legal advice

How the assessment can be organised

The process varies with the type of refusal and urgency reported by health professionals.

  1. 01

    Initial screening

    Identifying the request, response received, urgency reported by the doctor and plan type.

  2. 02

    Coverage classification

    Checking the contract, Rol, usage guidelines and any exclusion.

  3. 03

    Evidence checks

    Examining the prescription, report, reference numbers, refusal and, where needed, registration and evidence.

  4. 04

    Choosing the route

    Choosing between reassessment, the ANS, negotiation, Procon or court action according to risks and urgency.

  5. 05

    Ongoing assistance

    Following up responses and actions taken, without promising a timeframe or outcome.

Alex Rodrigues Alves, the Brazilian lawyer responsible for assistance

Who advises you

Alex Rodrigues Alves

Lawyer with postgraduate qualifications in Brazilian public law and constitutional law, practising Brazilian consumer law; these fields relate to fundamental rights, contracts and relations with operators.

  • Postgraduate qualification in Brazilian public law
  • Postgraduate qualification in Brazilian constitutional law
  • Education in Law, Accounting and Economics
  • Practice in Brazilian consumer law

These qualifications are not presented as medical or health law specialisations.

View education and professional registrations →

Frequently asked questions

Questions about coverage refusals

The answers provide general criteria and do not replace individual medical or legal assessment.

Is the ANS Rol exhaustive or illustrative?

In ADI 7.265, the STF held that the Rol is a mandatory reference, but treatment outside it may exceptionally be covered when all the technical criteria established in the ruling are met.

What are the criteria for treatment outside the Rol?

A prescription by a qualified treating doctor or dentist; no express ANS refusal or pending update proposal; no suitable therapeutic alternative in the Rol; scientific evidence of effectiveness and safety; and Anvisa registration. The criteria are cumulative.

Does a medical prescription guarantee coverage?

No. A prescription is essential, but coverage depends on the applicable treatment rules. For requests outside the Rol, the STF also required technical assessment and prohibited decisions based only on the report or prescription submitted by the party.

Must the operator provide a written refusal?

RN 623/2024 requires refusal of authorisation to be recorded and explained in detail in plain language, identifying the contractual clause or statutory provision used, whether or not the beneficiary requests it.

Must the plan provide a reference number?

Yes. Regulation requires a reference number to be provided as the first step at the start of contact, whatever channel the beneficiary uses.

Can I ask the operator itself to reassess the request?

Yes. The refusal must include information about reassessment of the healthcare request by the operator's ombudsman. The timeframe and appropriateness of this stage must be checked for the case.

Must I complain to the ANS before going to court?

The NIP may resolve or clarify some complaints, but strategy depends on urgency and documents. For requests outside the Rol, the STF requires courts to check the prior request to the operator and refusal, unreasonable delay or failure to respond.

What is the NIP deadline?

According to the ANS, the operator has five working days to answer healthcare complaints and ten working days for other complaints. These complaint deadlines differ from maximum deadlines for actually providing each service.

Does urgent or emergency care guarantee immediate coverage?

RN 623 requires an immediate response to requests classified as urgent or emergencies, but coverage, waiting periods and scope of care depend on Law No 9.656/1998, the contract and clinical classification. Seek medical assistance without waiting for legal advice.

Can a plan limit the length of a hospital stay?

STJ Súmula 302 treats a contractual time limit on hospital admission as unfair. Nevertheless, the treating doctor must document the indication and need for continued care.

How are allegations of pre-existing illness assessed?

STJ Súmula 609 treats refusal for pre-existing illness as unlawful if the operator neither required medical tests before contracting nor demonstrated the insured person's bad faith. The health declaration and contractual history must be examined.

Does the Brazilian Consumer Protection Code apply?

STJ Súmula 608 establishes that the Consumer Protection Code applies to health plan contracts, except those administered by self-managed entities.

Does every improper refusal lead to non-material damages?

No. In Theme 1.365, the STJ held that an improper refusal alone does not give rise to presumed non-material damage. Additional factors and effects sufficient to go beyond ordinary upset or inconvenience must be shown.

Can someone who paid for treatment seek reimbursement?

Reimbursement depends on the contract, network availability, prior contact, urgency, refusal and receipts. It is not automatic and must be assessed individually.

Can an urgent court decision be requested?

An application for urgent relief may be assessed where there is a likelihood of entitlement and risk of harm. Whether and when it is granted are matters for the court and cannot be promised.

Can the plan cancel a contract because of court proceedings?

Bringing proceedings is not, by itself, a legitimate contractual basis for cancellation. However, termination rules differ for individual, family and group plans and require separate assessment.

Can I send tests through the form?

Do not send tests, ICD codes, prescriptions or medical files through the initial form. Health data is sensitive; if assessment proceeds, the firm will identify an appropriate channel.

Can services be provided online?

Yes. Legal appointments are available online throughout Brazil and in person in Ceilândia Sul, Brasília/DF, subject to availability.

Related content

WhatsApp messages can be received in different languages. Telephone calls are available in Portuguese, English and Spanish.

Initial contact

Tell us what was requested and what response you received

State the plan, request date, whether there is a reference number and the operator's stated reason, without medical details.

Protection of health data

Do not include diagnoses, ICD codes, test results or clinical details, or send prescriptions or medical files at this initial contact. If assessment proceeds, an appropriate channel will be identified.

This form prepares a message in your browser. Avoid health information, information about children and details of legal proceedings. See the Privacy Policy.

WhatsApp